Cancel
Secure Checkout
AboutFAQ
    • Log in
    Log in

    Browse by categories

    Collections
    Bookstores
    Shelves
    Pango AI
    Popular Authors
    Popular Book Series
    Sell your books
    About Us
    Blog
    Market Guide
    Help Center
    Contact Us
    Cancel

    Shop

    • Bookstores
    • Collections
    • Categories
    • Authors
    • Gift cards
    • Shelves
    • Series

    Sell

    • Sellers Resource Hub
    • Ambassador
    • Market Guide

    Company

    • About Us
    • Blog
    • Trust and Safety

    Help

    • Help Center
    • Contact Us
    • PangoBucks FAQ
    • Feature Requests
    • © PangoBooks 2025. All rights reserved.
    • Terms of Use
    • Privacy Policy

    Pango Buyer Protection

    PangoBooks money back guarantee. Learn more

    Recently Viewed

    Pango
    Pango AI
    Your personal Pangolin book shopper is here to help you find the perfect book!

    Chat with Pango

    Categories
    Fiction
    Young Adult

    by: Sarah Gailey

    When We Were Magic

    When We Were Magic
    When We Were Magic
    When We Were Magic
    When We Were Magic

    $5.00

    Discover more

    When We Were Magic

    When We Were Magic

    By: Sarah Gailey

    13 copies available

    Condition

    Used
    New / Like New

    Format

    Paperback
    Hardcover
    This shop is having a sale!
    Get $1.00 off when you spend $5.00 Get an additional $5.00 off when you spend $15.00
    Get free shipping!
    Free shipping when you spend $10.00

    More from this author

    More books by Sarah Gailey

    Just Like Home

    Sarah Gailey

    4.4

    Just Like Home

    $8.00
    American Hippo

    Sarah Gailey

    American Hippo

    Sold Out

    The Echo Wife

    Sarah Gailey

    5.0

    The Echo Wife

    $3.00
    Someone in Time

    Nina Allan

    Someone in Time

    Sold Out

    The Echo Wife

    Sarah Gailey

    3.4

    The Echo Wife

    $5.00$7.50
    Magic for Liars

    Sarah Gailey

    3.5

    Magic for Liars

    $4.00$8.00
    The Mythic Dream

    John Chu

    The Mythic Dream

    Sold Out

    Eat the Rich SC

    Sarah Gailey

    Eat the Rich SC

    $10.00$11.00
    River of Teeth

    Sarah Gailey

    River of Teeth

    $2.99

    Similar books

    Mexican Gothic

    Silvia Moreno-García

    3.9

    Mexican Gothic

    $4.00
    The Summer Cottage

    Viola Shipman

    3.8

    The Summer Cottage

    $6.00
    Master of One

    Jaida Jones

    Master of One

    $10.00
    Lies We Sing to the Sea

    Sarah Underwood

    Lies We Sing to the Sea

    $9.00
    The Very Nice Box

    Eve Gleichman

    4.5

    The Very Nice Box

    $4.00$5.00
    I Think I Love You

    Auriane Desombre

    5.0

    I Think I Love You

    $5.00
    Within These Wicked Walls

    Lauren Blackwood

    3.4

    Within These Wicked Walls

    $4.50$5.00
    Black Candle Women

    Diane Marie Brown

    Black Candle Women

    $6.00
    Prisoner of Night and Fog

    Anne Blankman

    Prisoner of Night and Fog

    $4.00
    Ariadne

    Jennifer Saint

    4.3

    Ariadne

    $9.50$15.00
    Shrines of Gaiety

    Kate Atkinson

    Shrines of Gaiety

    $5.00
    Verity

    Colleen Hoover

    4.1

    Verity

    $5.00$6.00
    The Midnight Library

    Matt Haig

    3.8

    The Midnight Library

    $5.00
    Teaching My Mother How to Give Birth

    Warsan Shire

    Teaching My Mother How to Give Birth

    $4.00

    Seller Description

    Read once!

    Overview

    Publisher Description

    A moving, darkly funny novel about six teens whose magic goes wildly awry from Magic for Liars author Sarah Gailey, who Chuck Wendig calls an “author to watch.” Keeping your magic a secret is hard. Be...

    Read more

    Product Details

    Category - Fiction / Young Adult

    Format - Paperback

    Condition - Like New

    Listed - 23 days ago

    Wishes - 1

    Ships From - Michigan

    Est. Publication Date - Jun 2021

    Be the first one to review

    Review the book today!

    Rate the book
    Published
    Drafts

    Meet the seller

    Becca Cadeau
    Active Today
    Becca Cadeau
    (1)