Priscilla and Gerald's preparations for their upcoming nuptials are interrupted when Gerald's heirloom eighteenth century ship's figurehead is stolen from the East Shore Historical Museum. While the police try to track down the culprit, elderly Alzheimer's patient Tom Campbell claims he knows how it was done, but he doesn't remember who did it or when. It soon appears, however, that the thief would rather get rid of the old man than game him remember to much. Can Priscilla find the figurehead and the thief before Tom is silenced forever?