What readers are saying about this book

Summarized by Pango AI

PangoBooks readers have mixed feelings about Adrienne Young's debut adult novel. Many appreciate the atmospheric setting, the intertwining of magic, romance, and mystery, and the depth of the island’s presence in the story, which adds a compelling layer to the narrative. However, some found the book lacking in magical elements, with several noting they expected more in terms of magic and witchcraft, feeling the story leaned more towards a slow-burn mystery and romance. While some readers were captivated and unable to put the book down, others felt it was boring, with portions of the story deemed unnecessary and characters that were underdeveloped. Despite its flaws, many still found it an engaging read with notable fall vibes and a good mystery element.